If you’re planning a Sandals honeymoon, there’s a good chance you’ve narrowed it down to two incredible resorts: Sandals Saint Vincent and the Grenadines and Sandals Grande St. Lucian.

It’s one of the most common questions I see in Sandals travel groups—and recently, dozens of experienced guests weighed in with their opinions.

The interesting part?

There wasn’t a clear winner. Instead, the answers revealed that these two resorts appeal to different types of honeymooners.

Having now visited both destinations myself, here’s my honest comparison.

Why So Many People Choose Sandals Grande St. Lucian

Reading through the discussion, one theme appeared over and over again:

The beach.

Grande St. Lucian consistently earns praise for having one of the nicest beaches in the entire Sandals collection.

Why?

• Long stretch of soft white sand
• Calm Caribbean water
• Incredible swimming
• Excellent sunset views
• Beautiful location between Rodney Bay and the Atlantic

If spending every day on a postcard-perfect beach is your honeymoon dream, Grande St. Lucian is difficult to beat.

Many guests also love that you’re staying near Rodney Bay, giving you access to shopping, nightlife and some excellent excursions.

Why Couples Are Falling in Love with Sandals Saint Vincent

Although Grande received slightly more votes in the discussion, the comments about Saint Vincent were incredibly enthusiastic.

Guests repeatedly mentioned:

• The stunning modern rooms
• Butler villas with private pools
• Peaceful atmosphere
• Gorgeous mountain scenery
• Shorter airport transfer

Saint Vincent feels very different from most Caribbean resorts.

Instead of a busy beach destination, you’re surrounded by lush rainforest, dramatic cliffs and one of the most naturally beautiful islands in the Caribbean.

It feels more exclusive and untouched.

Personally, I think Sandals created something really special here.

Which Resort Is More Romantic?

This depends entirely on what romance looks like to you.

Choose Saint Vincent if you want:

• Privacy
• A quieter honeymoon
• Luxury accommodations
• Incredible mountain scenery
• A resort that feels brand new

The atmosphere is calm, intimate and sophisticated.

Choose Grande St. Lucian if you want:

• A spectacular beach
• More social energy
• Plenty of activities
• Easy access to excursions
• Classic Caribbean honeymoon vibes

It offers that iconic tropical honeymoon many couples imagine.

What About the Airport Transfer?

This was another major topic in the discussion.

Sandals Saint Vincent

One of the biggest advantages is the shorter transfer from Argyle International Airport—roughly 45 minutes.

If you’re staying in select Butler-level accommodations, you can even choose an optional boat transfer, which many guests rave about.

Sandals Grande St. Lucian

The drive from Hewanorra International Airport takes around 90 minutes.

Many couples choose to upgrade to:

• Helicopter transfer
• Ferry transfer

Both turn the journey into part of the vacation rather than simply transportation.

Which Resort Has Better Rooms?

This is where I give Saint Vincent the edge.

The accommodations feel incredibly fresh, contemporary and luxurious.

Some of my favourites include:

• Bamboo Palm rooms
• Butler Villas
• One-bedroom suites with private pools

Grande St. Lucian still has excellent accommodations—especially the beachfront categories—but Saint Vincent simply feels newer and more modern.

Which Resort Has Better Scenery?

Both are breathtaking, but they’re beautiful in completely different ways.

Saint Vincent

• Rainforest
• Mountains
• Waterfalls
• Untouched landscapes

Nature lovers will be in heaven.

Saint Lucia

• The Caribbean Sea
• Palm-lined beaches
• Pigeon Island
• Dramatic volcanic mountains nearby

Saint Lucia feels like the quintessential Caribbean postcard.

My Recommendation

If a client asked me today which resort I would recommend, I’d ask one question first:

What matters most on your honeymoon?

Choose Sandals Saint Vincent if you want:

• Luxury over nightlife
• Privacy
• Stunning new accommodations
• Incredible natural scenery
• A quieter, more exclusive experience

Choose Sandals Grande St. Lucian if you want:

• One of Sandals’ best beaches
• More activity and entertainment
• Classic Caribbean honeymoon vibes
• Easier access to excursions
• A lively atmosphere

My Final Thoughts

Here’s the good news:

There isn’t a wrong answer.

Both Sandals Saint Vincent and Sandals Grande St. Lucian are among my favourite resorts in the Sandals collection, and both deliver an unforgettable honeymoon.

The best choice comes down to your travel style.

If you dream of waking up in a luxurious suite surrounded by rainforest, choose Saint Vincent.

If you’ve always imagined endless white sand, turquoise water and one of the Caribbean’s most beautiful beaches, Grande St. Lucian may be exactly what you’re looking for.

As someone who knows these destinations inside and out, I help couples compare the details that don’t always come across on a website—room locations, beach differences, dining, transfers, and which resort truly matches your honeymoon vision.

Connect with Pink Palm Travel to book your next stay at Sandals Saint Vincent or Grande St Lucian.

Related Blog Posts

• Choosing Between Sandals Saint Vincent and Sandals Grenada
• Book St. Vincent & The Grenadines with a Top Travel Advisor
• Why Sandals Saint Vincent Is One of My Most Booked Sandals Resorts Right Now